An HOA Board That Investigates First Gets Deference in Court

KEY TAKEAWAY

An HOA board that investigates first gets deference in court. In Harvey v. The Landing Homeowners Assn., 162 Cal.App.4th 809 (2008), a California appeals court upheld a Coronado board that let top floor owners keep up to 120 square feet of attic storage, because the board investigated, acted in good faith, and stayed inside the discretion its CC&Rs gave it. Boards do not get deference for ignoring their documents. They get it for doing the work first.

Most owner versus board fights are framed as the board either enforcing the rules or breaking them. This case shows the middle ground courts actually look for. The question was not whether attic storage was popular. It was whether the board had authority to allow a limited use, and whether it used that authority carefully.

What happened

The Landing is a four story, 92 unit condominium community in Coronado, built in 1987. Each of the 23 fourth floor units sits next to attic space that is common area on the condominium plan, and that space can only be reached from inside the adjacent unit.

For years, fourth floor owners used that attic space for storage. When an owner complained in 2002, the board inspected the fourth floor. It found 18 owners using between 50 and 288 square feet each, 10 of them over 120 square feet, and one owner who had turned part of the space into living space.

The board sent violation notices. Several owners pushed back, with legal opinions saying long use had created irrevocable rights. The board then chose a controlled fix instead of either ignoring the use or ordering everything removed at once. It created permission forms that capped use at 120 square feet for rough storage only, such as boxes and luggage, required compliance with the bylaws, the CC&Rs, and government rules, required each user to carry $1 million in liability insurance, and kept the right to end the permission for cause.

The board also checked outside the building. It met with City of Coronado inspectors, who said the space could be used for storage but not as living space, and later inspections found the units within the 120 square foot limit and in compliance with building and fire codes. It consulted its insurance broker, who found the storage use had not affected coverage or premiums. Owners later approved the related rule change by a vote of 56 to 7. In 2006, the board passed a resolution granting the exclusive use, relying in part on a California statute that allows a board to grant exclusive use of a nominal portion of common area to an individual owner.

One owner sued anyway, bringing claims for trespass, breach of fiduciary duty, and injunctive relief, and arguing the board had no authority to allow a use the CC&Rs regulated.

What the court decided

The trial court granted summary judgment for the association, and the Court of Appeal affirmed in Harvey v. The Landing Homeowners Assn., 162 Cal.App.4th 809 (2008).

The court applied the rule from Lamden v. La Jolla Shores Clubdominium Homeowners Assn. (1999) 21 Cal.4th 249. In plain English, that rule says courts should defer to a duly constituted board decision when the board, upon reasonable investigation, in good faith and with regard for the best interests of the association and its members, exercises discretion within the scope of its authority.

The court found those conditions met here. The CC&Rs gave the board sole and exclusive authority to manage the common area and to adopt reasonable rules for its use. Article IV, Section 11 allowed the board to designate storage areas. Article IV, Section 12 allowed the board to let an owner exclusively use a portion of common area if that portion was nominal in area, adjacent to the owner unit, and did not unreasonably interfere with any other owner use or enjoyment.

On those facts, 120 square feet counted as nominal. For all 23 fourth floor units combined, the approved total was 2,760 square feet, a little more than 1 percent of the total building area and about 3.5 percent of the total common area. The court also rejected the claim that the decision was invalid just because some directors owned fourth floor units and voted for it, and it noted the full membership vote in favor of the rule change.

The trespass claim failed because the fourth floor owners were using the space with the board’s express permission. The court then left in place an award to the association of $10,220.46 in costs and $116,794.30 in attorney fees, the figures listed on The Landing profile.

What the case did not decide

This ruling does not say a board can ignore its CC&Rs. The court was clear that deference does not protect a board that acts outside its governing documents. The board won because its documents gave it discretion over this exact kind of decision, and because the record showed investigation, outside checks, conditions, and a member vote.

It also does not say every small common area use is nominal, or that every board compromise will be upheld. A different cap, a space other owners could actually use, or a decision made with no investigation could come out differently. The holding turns on authority plus process, not on attic storage itself.

Compare this with our earlier explainer on CC&R arbitration clauses and the Pinnacle case. There, a clause in the recorded CC&Rs decided where a fight would be heard. Here, language in the CC&Rs decided how much room the board had to settle a fight inside the community. In both cases, the document wording mattered more than anyone expected.

What to check in your own community

If your board faces a long running common area use, or you are buying into a building where one exists, look for these five things.

  1. Authority. Do the CC&Rs let the board designate the use, grant a limited exclusive use, or adopt a rule for it? Quote the section, do not rely on a summary.
  2. Investigation. Did the board inspect, measure, and write down what it found before it decided?
  3. Outside checks. Did it confirm building, fire, and insurance limits in writing?
  4. Conditions. Is the permission written, capped, and revocable for cause, or is it an open ended understanding?
  5. Cost risk. If an owner sues and loses, fee shifting can be large. In this case the fee and cost award together topped $127,000. Our guide on how to read an HOA budget in 20 minutes shows where legal costs show up after a fight like this ends.

Then browse Coronado HOAs and read the profile for any community you are considering, including its legal history, before you assume a common area arrangement is either settled or a problem.

The bottom line

Deference is earned, not automatic. A board that can show authority in its CC&Rs, a real investigation, good faith, and regard for the whole community is far more likely to be upheld than a board that acts first and documents later. That is the practical lesson of The Landing case, and it applies to far more than attic storage.

KEY TAKEAWAY

In Harvey v. The Landing, 162 Cal.App.4th 809 (2008), the court deferred to a board that investigated a long running attic storage use, capped it at 120 square feet, added conditions and insurance, and acted under CC&R sections that gave it that discretion. Authority plus a careful process is what earned the deference.

Source: the full opinion is reproduced at Epsten, APC, Harvey v. The Landing Homeowners Assn., 162 Cal.App.4th 809 (2008), https://www.epsten.com/harvey-v-the-landing-homeowners-assn/

Disclaimer: This article is general information only, not legal advice. HOA rules and the deference a court gives a board vary by state, by the wording of each association CC&Rs, and by the facts of each dispute. Check the CC&Rs for the specific community you are considering, and consult a California HOA attorney where the stakes are high.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top