By Brian R, Founder of HOAGrades —
Key takeaway
Most HOA problems do not come out of nowhere. They cluster in a few buckets — money, maintenance, insurance, and governance — and buyers can spot most of them before closing by asking for the right documents.
Special assessments
When reserves are underfunded, owners get hit with large one-time bills. A special assessment can arrive with little warning, and it is due whether or not the owner agrees with the project behind it.
Example
At Villa Moura in San Clemente, a 198-unit community, owners faced a $5.15M emergency roof assessment in fall 2026 — about $26,000 per unit. It was levied under the emergency statute without an owner vote, and a recall effort is now underway.
Construction defects
Defects in roofs, plumbing, balconies, and other shared systems can turn into years of:
- Claims
- Repairs
- Legal costs
Even a strong early result does not guarantee a final one.
Example
At Acqua Vista in San Diego, defective cast-iron pipes led to a jury award of $26,038,909. That judgment was reversed on appeal on January 26, 2017 (case D068406). The story is a caution about how long and uncertain defect fights can be, not a win to count on.
Insurance and lending trouble
Insurance and lending problems often arrive together. If a building cannot get or keep adequate coverage, or cannot pass a lender review, owners can face higher costs and buyers can face trouble getting a loan.
Since August 3, 2026, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac ended fast-track condo reviews, so most larger buildings need full project review of:
- Reserves
- Insurance
- Litigation
Open SB 326 balcony inspection findings can also make a condo non-warrantable until repaired.
Example
Del Mar Woods is a reminder that insurance does not always rescue an HOA. The HOA won only its duty-to-defend fight against its insurer (June 27, 2025, S.D. Cal. No. 24-cv-0779), while the underlying dispute ended in dismissal plus a $48,229 fee award.
Rising dues
Dues pressure usually comes from the same sources:
- Reserves that need rebuilding
- Rising insurance costs
- Deferred maintenance that can no longer wait
When those costs are not planned for, they show up as higher dues, special assessments, or both.
974
San Diego and Orange County HOAs tracked by HOAGrades
522
HOAs with verified dues
42
HOAs with tracked legal cases
Those figures show how common it is for dues, reserves, and legal exposure to sit side by side in the same community.
Governance and transparency
Some of the worst HOA surprises are governance problems:
- Boards that skip reserve planning
- Thin meeting minutes
- Owners who learn about a problem only when the bill arrives
Example
At Coronado Shores, a $3M special assessment was levied in 2026 with reserves reported at 11% funded, per a board candidate’s financial statement. Owners should not have to learn a number like that after the assessment is already levied.
What to check before you buy
Before you buy into an HOA, ask for these documents and read them before you remove contingencies:
- The current budget
- The most recent reserve study and its funding percentage
- Two years of meeting minutes
- Any special assessment history
- Pending or past litigation disclosures
- The SB 326 inspection summary — first inspections were due January 1, 2025, then every 9 years
If any of these are missing, vague, or out of date, ask why before you close.
Browse the HOA directory, read about legal battles, and check the HOA Health Report before you buy.
About the author
Brian R is the founder of HOAGrades. He spent 20+ years in Orange County, studied Business and Finance at Cal State Fullerton, and now lives in San Diego. He built HOAGrades because buying into an HOA shouldn’t mean buying blind: every dues figure, risk score, and legal record on the site is verified from a stated source, and nothing here is pay-to-rank.
