By Brian R, Founder of HOAGrades —
When you buy into an HOA, you buy into its finances too. Dues, special assessments, lawsuits, and repair backlogs are part of the real price, and they are all checkable before closing.
Why checking first is worth it
The point of checking before you buy is not just to know what to ask for — it is to protect yourself from costs and setbacks that are hard to undo after closing.
A surprise special assessment can cost tens of thousands per unit. At Villa Moura in San Clemente, with 198 units, a $5.15M emergency roof assessment in fall 2026 worked out to $26,000 per unit, levied without an owner vote.
A building-wide assessment can run into the millions. At Coronado Shores, a $3M special assessment levied in 2026 came with reserves reported at 11% funded.
Financing can also fall through late in the process. Since August 3, 2026, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac require full project review for most larger condo buildings, and open SB 326 inspection findings can make a condo non-warrantable until repaired — meaning a deal can die late in the process over something checkable in advance.
Defect and legal fights can drag on for years with uncertain outcomes. Acqua Vista‘s $26,038,909 jury award was reversed on appeal on January 26, 2017 (case D068406).
That is the asymmetry: looking up an HOA takes minutes and the directory is free; the surprise it can catch runs to five figures per household or a dead deal.
How to use HOAGrades
Look up any HOA by name or browse by city in the HOA directory. Each profile shows verified monthly dues where available, a risk band, and any tracked legal cases.
HOAGrades tracks 974 San Diego and Orange County HOAs, including 522 with verified dues, 42 with tracked legal cases, across 59 cities.
How to read a profile
Dues marked as verified come from listings or public records. If dues are shown as “not listed,” the dues are not publicly confirmed yet — ask for the current figure before you rely on it.
Risk bands — Low, Moderate, Elevated, and High — reflect legal, financial, physical, and governance signals. A higher band means more issues to check, not a final verdict on the home.
“Insufficient data” means there is not enough verified information to score the HOA. It does not mean the HOA is safe.
Five documents to ask for before you buy
- The current budget
- The most recent reserve study and its funding percentage
- Two years of meeting minutes
- Any special assessment history
- Pending or past litigation disclosures
- The SB 326 balcony inspection summary, where it applies — first inspections were due January 1, 2025, then every 9 years
Read these documents before you remove contingencies. If something is missing, ask for it in writing.
Red flags that should slow you down
- A recent or recurring special assessment
- An underfunded reserve
- Pending litigation or defect claims
- Dues well above similar buildings nearby
- Any open inspection findings
A red flag does not always mean you should walk away. It means you need clear answers, costs, and a timeline before you proceed.
Financing check
Since August 3, 2026, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac require full project review for most larger condo buildings, covering reserves, insurance, and litigation. Ask your lender early whether the building is warrantable, because an open inspection finding can block financing until repaired.
A sample health report
One health report consolidates litigation, special assessments, reserve funding, and dues trends in one place, so you can see how those risks fit together instead of checking them one by one.
That is where the value lies: litigation, a special assessment history, reserve funding, and dues trends are the signals that can point to a surprise cost, a financing problem, or a long legal fight — and seeing them together, before you remove contingencies, gives you a clearer basis for questions, costs, and a timeline.
See the HOA Health Report sample page for an example of what such a report brings together in one place.
Next steps
Start with the HOA directory, then read the Common HOA Problems page and the legal battles page for more background.
About the author
Brian R is the founder of HOAGrades. He spent 20+ years in Orange County, studied Business and Finance at Cal State Fullerton, and now lives in San Diego. He built HOAGrades because buying into an HOA shouldn’t mean buying blind: every dues figure, risk score, and legal record on the site is verified from a stated source, and nothing here is pay-to-rank.
