HOA legal fights are the most shareable thing in this space, because every one of them is really the same story: owners finding out too late what they actually bought into.
We track legal cases across the HOAs in our database. Most are dry one-line settlements. These three have real stakes, real numbers, and a lesson a buyer can use. Together they cover the three ways HOA money actually disappears: a board that skips the vote, a building defect that outlives its legal remedy, and an insurance policy that doesn’t do what the board thought it did.

1. Villa Moura, San Clemente — the $26,000 bill nobody voted on

In fall 2026, every owner at the 198-unit Vilamoura at Rancho San Clemente complex got the same bill: $26,000 each for a roof replacement, $5.15 million total. The board called it an emergency. Residents got one month to pay — in full, in two payments of $13,000, or $2,000 a month for six months and then $400 a month after that. Miss a payment and the HOA warned it would put a lien on the unit; letters reviewed by the LA Times said it could escalate as far as foreclosure.
The residents aren’t disputing that the roofs are old. They’re disputing the word “emergency.” Their case: the roofs aren’t leaking, only the underlayment needs replacing, and the board has known for years this was coming. Under California law, that distinction is everything. A board generally can’t impose a special assessment over 5% of the association’s annual budgeted gross expenses without a member vote — unless it’s a genuine emergency under Civil Code §5610: court-ordered, an immediate threat to health or safety, or something that couldn’t reasonably have been foreseen when the budget was adopted. The board also has to put a written finding in its minutes explaining why it qualifies. “We knew for years and didn’t save for it” is not on that list.
The board’s own lawyer, James R. McCormick, has effectively conceded the underlying point, acknowledging that roof maintenance “should have been planned for and performed in prior years.” His argument is that a recent independent expert report forced the board’s hand: sloppy original tile installation, water getting in, and a waterproofing membrane that is “deteriorated and no longer watertight” — with a strong El Niño winter coming. The total bid, he said, was $5.2 million, including $500,000 for fire suppression system repairs folded into the same project.
Residents organized fast: a legal claim challenging how the assessment was imposed, a recall election to unseat the board, and their own winter weatherproofing estimate of about $400 per resident. Many are already paying the $2,000-a-month plan on top of dues that already run $500-plus a month. Residents say 60% of the complex is seniors. No court has ruled yet — the claim is pending and the recall is underway.
What to check before you buy: three numbers tell you whether you’re the next Villa Moura — the reserve fund’s percent-funded level, the age of the roof, and whether the last reserve study flagged the roof as near end-of-life. If reserves are thin and the roof is 25-plus years old, a special assessment isn’t a risk, it’s a schedule.
The HOAGrades angle: this is the story our data should tell before the news does. The publishable version is a standing feature: “assessments nobody voted on” — every emergency assessment in the database, with the per-unit dollar figure, the stated reason, and whether the underlying problem was foreseeable.
See the Villa Moura profile for the case details we track.
2. Acqua Vista, San Diego — the $24 million judgment that vanished
Acqua Vista is a San Diego condo complex built with cast-iron pipe manufactured in China. The pipes leaked and corroded so badly they choked off the useful life of the plumbing and sewer system. The HOA sued the pipe supplier MWI, Inc. under California’s construction-standards law (SB 800, Civil Code §895 et seq.).
The jury believed the HOA completely. It found the pipes leaked, found they corroded, and put damages at $26,038,909: $18.5 million for repairs, $7.13 million to relocate residents and store their belongings, and $408,909 for investigation. Fault: 92% MWI, 8% the other supplier, 0% installer, 0% HOA. In March 2015 the trial court entered a $23,955,796.28 judgment against MWI.
Then the Fourth District Court of Appeal took the whole thing away. On January 26, 2017 (case D068406), the court reversed and ordered judgment entered for MWI. The reason was narrow and brutal: under §936, a claim against a material supplier requires proof the supplier caused the violation through a negligent act or a breach of contract. The HOA proved the pipes were defective. It never proved MWI did anything negligent or breached anything. Defective product, proven in court, $24 million judgment, gone on a theory-of-the-case error.
What to check before you buy: in any condo built roughly 2000–2010, ask what the waste and sewer lines are made of and whether there has been a single leak, ever. One pinhole leak in a cast-iron stack is not a plumbing problem — it’s the first symptom of a system-wide failure that costs eight figures to fix. Also ask whether the HOA has ever filed a defect claim, and whether the 10-year SB 800 window has already closed. Most of these buildings are past it now, which means the cost lands on owners, not builders.
The HOAGrades angle: a legal row should carry the full arc — filed, verdict, judgment, reversed — not just the biggest number. We originally listed this case as a $23.9 million judgment; the reversal is now reflected in the profile, because publishing “Acqua Vista won $24M” without the ending would be misinformation. A “case tracker” format, one page per dispute updated as it moves, is content no other HOA site is doing. What happened after the 2017 remand is not on the public record, so we don’t claim an ending that isn’t there.
See the Acqua Vista profile for the case details we track.
3. Del Mar Woods, Del Mar — the insurance policy that covered nothing until a lawyer wrote a letter
It started as a noise complaint. Gregory and Kathleen Haidet owned a condo at Del Mar Woods. The upstairs neighbor installed hardwood flooring with the wrong sound barrier, and every footstep came through. The Haidets complained to the board starting in January 2022. The board sent two violation notices and then stopped.
On June 8, 2022, the Haidets’ lawyer sent the board a letter titled “Demand to Enforce CC&Rs and Rules/Regulations,” demanding “immediate action.” The next day, the HOA tendered the matter to its insurer, Philadelphia Indemnity, under a claims-made Community Association policy running March 2022 to March 2023. The insurer said no: the claim was first made in January 2022, before the policy started, so there was no coverage.
On June 27, 2025, a federal judge ruled for the HOA. The whole case turned on one word in the policy: a “claim” means “a written demand for monetary or non-monetary relief.” The court went through the Haidets’ emails one by one and found that none of them was a demand — complaints and requests, not demands. The first actual demand was the lawyer’s June 8 letter, inside the policy period. So the insurer owed a defense, and refusing to defend breached the policy. The underlying neighbor fight had already ended with the HOA winning dismissal and a $48,229 attorney-fee award.
What to check before you buy: whether your HOA’s liability policy is claims-made or occurrence-based — most owners have no idea, and the difference decides whether last year’s complaint becomes this year’s uncovered lawsuit. And how the board handles the paper trail: every owner complaint that sits unanswered is a future coverage dispute. A board that answers complaints in writing, fast, isn’t just being polite. It’s protecting the policy.
The HOAGrades angle: insurance is the missing column in our database. We track dues, reserves, and lawsuits. We don’t yet track whether the master policy is claims-made or occurrence, whether the carrier has non-renewed, or whether the HOA is fighting its insurer. That’s the next data layer — and the one most likely to predict the next special assessment, because when insurance won’t pay, owners do. Note the limit of this story: the 2025 ruling decided the duty to defend only, not full bad-faith damages.
See the Del Mar Woods profile for the case details we track.
Check your HOA before you buy
One story, one lesson, one check. That’s the format we’ll keep using for this series — and the series itself is the argument for why the database exists. Search any San Diego or Orange County HOA on HOAGrades before you write an offer, and read the legal history before the dues figure. Start with the HOA Directory.
Sources
- Villa Moura: NY Post (Oct 5, 2026), Moneywise, Capital Digest, LA Times reporting on the assessment, lien letters, and board attorney statements.
- Acqua Vista: Court of Appeal opinion, case D068406, filed Jan 26, 2017 (https://law.justia.com/cases/california/court-of-appeal/2017/d068406.html).
- Del Mar Woods: Federal order, S.D. Cal. No. 24-cv-0779, June 27, 2025; underlying state appeal, Haidet v. Del Mar Woods, D082923 (2024).
