Your CC&Rs Can Send a Construction Defect Fight to Arbitration, Even If You Never Signed the Clause

KEY TAKEAWAY

Your CC&Rs can send a construction defect fight to arbitration, even if you never signed the clause yourself. In California, the state Supreme Court has held that a developer-written arbitration clause in recorded CC&Rs can bind the HOA, because owners and the association accept the CC&Rs by taking title. Read the dispute resolution section before you buy, not after a defect shows up.

Most buyers read CC&Rs for pets, parking, and rentals. They skip the dispute resolution clause near the back. That clause can decide where a defect fight happens, whether a jury ever hears it, and how much it costs to pursue. This case explains why.

What happened

The developer, Pinnacle Market Development, built the Pinnacle Museum Tower Condominium in downtown San Diego. The community is listed on HOAGrades as The Pinnacle, at 550 Front St, with 182 units, built in 2005.

Before any unit was sold, the developer drafted and recorded the Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions, the CC&Rs. The CC&Rs created the owners association, the Pinnacle Museum Tower Association, to manage and maintain the property.

Article XVIII of those CC&Rs said that by accepting a deed, the association and each owner agree to waive a jury trial and to resolve any construction dispute with the developer only through binding arbitration, under the Federal Arbitration Act and the California Arbitration Act. The clause applied only to a construction dispute where the developer was named as a party, and it could not be amended without the developer’s written consent.

Later, the association sued the developer, alleging construction defects caused damage to the project. It sought recovery for damage to its own property and for damage to the separate interests of the owners who make up its membership. The developer moved to compel arbitration under Article XVIII.

What the court decided

The trial court found the Federal Arbitration Act applied and that the clause was an agreement to arbitrate, but it invalidated the agreement as unconscionable. The Court of Appeal affirmed.

The California Supreme Court disagreed. In Pinnacle Museum Tower Assn. v. Pinnacle Market Development (US), LLC, 55 Cal.4th 223 (2012), it held that the arbitration clause binds the association and is not unconscionable.

The court’s reasoning was plain. Under the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, the covenants and terms in a recorded declaration reflect written promises and agreements that can be enforced against the association, even though the association did not exist as an entity independent of the developer when the declaration was drafted and recorded. Accepting a deed meant accepting the CC&Rs, including Article XVIII. The buyers’ purchase agreements also said that by accepting the grant deed, the buyer accepted and agreed to comply with the recorded CC&Rs, and they initialed a provision agreeing to comply with Article XVIII.

That is the point buyers miss. You do not have to sign a separate arbitration agreement. Taking title to a unit in a community whose recorded CC&Rs contain the clause can be enough.

What the case did not decide

This ruling was about where the fight happens, not about whether the building was defective or who was liable for any defect. The court decided the clause was binding and not unconscionable. It did not decide the merits of the defect claims.

The underlying construction defect action was later settled as of August 2014, according to the HOAGrades legal record for The Pinnacle. The settlement amount is not public. The profile lists the case status as settled.

What to check before you buy

Read the dispute resolution section of the CC&Rs, not just the rules section. Look for these five things.

  1. Arbitration or jury waiver. Does the clause require binding arbitration for construction disputes, and does it waive a jury trial?
  2. Who it covers. Does it bind only individual owners, or the association as well?
  3. Who the other party can be. Does it apply only to disputes with the developer, or to disputes with other parties too?
  4. Whether it can be changed. Can owners amend the clause, or does it require the developer’s written consent?
  5. What it leaves out. Does it cover construction defects only, or other disputes such as assessment and governance fights?

Then ask for the litigation and defect disclosure. Our guide to the documents to read before buying into an HOA lists litigation and defect disclosure as item 10, and explains why a vague disclosure deserves a follow up question in writing. If the packet shows a past defect case, ask what it covered, whether it is settled, and whether any repair or funding issue is still open.

Finally, check the budget for the cost of disputes. Our guide on how to read an HOA budget in 20 minutes shows where legal costs sit in the small lines owners often skip. Rising legal costs can point to a dispute, even when the CC&Rs look routine.

The bottom line

A CC&R clause written before you bought can still bind the association you later join. That is not a reason to avoid condos. It is a reason to read the dispute resolution clause the same way you read the dues figure and the reserve study. Browse San Diego HOAs to compare communities, and check the profile for any legal history before you write an offer. Deference cuts the other way too: our explainer on board deference and The Landing attic case shows how a board that investigated first, acted in good faith, and stayed inside its CC&Rs was upheld on appeal.

KEY TAKEAWAY

In the Pinnacle case, a developer-written arbitration clause in recorded CC&Rs was held binding on the HOA, because the association and its owners accept those CC&Rs by taking title. Read that clause before you buy. It decides where a defect fight goes, long before any defect is found.

Source: the full opinion is reproduced at Epsten, APC, Pinnacle Museum Tower Assn. v. Pinnacle Market Development, 55 Cal.4th 223 (2012), https://www.epsten.com/pinnacle-museum-v-pinnacle/

Disclaimer: This article is general information only, not legal advice. HOA rules and the effect of an arbitration clause vary by state, by the wording of each association’s CC&Rs, and by the facts of each dispute. Check the CC&Rs for the specific community you are considering, and consult a California HOA attorney where the stakes are high.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top