A companion to the HOAGrades San Diego HOA Health Report
Published by HOAGrades, October 22, 2026. Data as of October 22, 2026. This is general information, not financial or legal advice, and not a “do not buy” list. A watchlist entry means: read the documents before you close. Every figure below is from HOAGrades’ verified database; where a figure rests on a single or weak source, that is stated.
See the San Diego HOA Health Report — October 2026.
Scope: San Diego County only (812 HOAs in the HOAGrades database). Orange County HOAs, including Villa Moura, are not on this list — they belong on a separate Orange County watchlist.
How an HOA gets on this list: HOAGrades risk score Moderate (25–49) or Elevated (50+) AND at least one forward-looking reason to watch: a levied assessment, a filed or pending case, a settled case with ongoing relevance, dues acceleration, or dues in the top 10% of the county. HOAs with settled cases only and no other signal are in the appendix table, not the headline tiers. 49 San Diego County HOAs score Moderate or Elevated; 6 are on “Watch now,” 5 on “Keep an eye,” and the rest are listed in the appendix with their scores and dues.
Watch now — read the documents before you close
1. Coronado Shores — Coronado — Elevated 68/100 — Dues $831–$1,640/mo
Why watch: $3,000,000 special assessment levied February 9, 2026 for El Mirador Tower No. 9 (about $20,270 per unit, 148 owners). Per the official election packet: $1.8M on fire systems, pumps and fuel tanks, a new roof, building-wide air conditioning and water-leak detection; $500K to operating capital; $700K to reserves. Reserves rose from 11% to 34% funded — better, still not fully funded. The same packet flags sewer-pipe condition as a possible future assessment. Dues acceleration is also high (about 10.5% CAGR on genuine history years). No owner lawsuits challenging the assessment were found in the October 22, 2026 re-check.
Ask for: the election packet, the reserve study, and any sewer-pipe report.
2. Seascape Sur — Solana Beach — Elevated 60/100 — Dues $960–$1,076/mo
Why watch: a levied special assessment of $180,000 per unit for exterior property improvements is recorded. Caution, stated plainly: this figure rests on a single weak source and is treated as provisional in HOAGrades’ database — it is included here because a figure that large, even provisional, is exactly what a buyer should verify, not because it is confirmed. Dues acceleration about 6.9% CAGR.
Ask for: the assessment notice, the vote record, and the reserve study — and treat any seller claim about this assessment as unverified until those documents are in hand.
3. Pacific Gate — San Diego — Moderate 49/100 — Dues $2,300/mo
Why watch: an SB-800 construction-defect claim is filed (pre-litigation). Dues are $2,300/mo — 99.6th percentile in San Diego County — and dues acceleration is about 9.4% CAGR. Owner-occupancy is recorded at just 4%, which matters for Fannie/Freddie loan review.
Ask for: the defect claim status, the reserve study, and the owner-occupancy figure in the resale package.
4. Savina — San Diego — Moderate 33/100 — Dues $1,300/mo
Why watch: an SB-800 construction-defect claim is filed (pre-litigation). Dues are 96.7th percentile in the county, with 6 years of dues history — the deepest history among the newer Moderate entries. This HOA joined the report-ready set in the October 22, 2026 enrichment run.
Ask for: the defect claim status and the dues-history trend for the specific unit type.
5. Smart Corner — San Diego — Moderate 44/100 — Dues $952–$1,072/mo
Why watch: two cases — a construction-defect case settled in 2017, and a legal-malpractice arbitration filed (database records 2020; a separate filing note says March 2026 — that date conflict is unresolved and flagged for verification, not smoothed over). Dues history is still thin (3 years; 2 more needed for a 5-year trend).
Ask for: the malpractice arbitration status and the current reserve study.
6. Ambiance HOA — San Marcos — Moderate 34/100 — Dues $479/mo
Why watch: a governance dispute is pending — a flag-fine dispute with $100 fines per resident, filed June 1, 2026. The dues are modest; the watch reason is governance, not money. Pending disputes are worth watching because they can become fines, liens, or rule changes.
Ask for: the dispute record and the current fine schedule.
Keep an eye — dues pressure, not a legal event
These HOAs have no headline legal event, but their dues math deserves a second look:
- Meridian — San Diego — Moderate 32 — $1,950/mo. Dues acceleration about 11.0% CAGR (highest among Moderate/Elevated HOAs with genuine history), 99.4th percentile in the county.
- Monarch Villas — Carlsbad — Moderate 28 — $585/mo. Dues acceleration about 9.5% CAGR.
- Sommerset by the Lake — San Marcos — Moderate 32 — $563/mo. Dues acceleration about 8.2% CAGR.
- North Coast Village — Oceanside — Moderate 36 — $1,000/mo. Dues acceleration about 6.2% CAGR; owner-occupancy recorded at 5.2% — very low, which can affect loan review.
- Marina Towers — Oceanside — Moderate 32 — $920/mo. Dues acceleration about 5.8% CAGR; 92.4th percentile in the county.
History a buyer should still know
Settled or decided cases do not vanish from a building’s history. These are not “watch now” items, but a buyer should know they happened:
- Discovery at Cortez Hill — San Diego — Moderate 46 — $1,189–$1,274/mo. Construction-defect litigation settled, plus a 2010 appellate judgment and a 2017 settled assessment dispute.
- Del Mar Woods — Del Mar — Moderate 36 — $884/mo. Two 2022–2025 judgments, including a $48,229 attorney-fee award to the HOA and a duty-to-defend insurance ruling.
- Pacific Pines Racquet Club — Encinitas — Moderate 35 — $471/mo. Defective-roofing case, $4,800,000 stipulated judgment.
- Acqua Vista — San Diego — Moderate 34 — $913–$970/mo. The $26,038,909 jury award became a $23,955,796.28 judgment — which was REVERSED on appeal in January 2017 (case D068406). Post-remand outcome is unverified. Do not quote the jury figure as a live judgment.
- La Jolla Terrace — San Diego — Moderate 30 — $432–$624/mo. A $10,000,000 settlement is reported by NBC 7; city documents confirm authorization, not the figure. Treat the figure as reported, not confirmed.
- Sapphire Tower — San Diego — Moderate 28 — $1,350/mo. $200M in defect claims asserted — a developer-side figure, not a judgment.
Appendix — all 49 San Diego County HOAs scoring Moderate or Elevated
Score, band, and current dues as of October 22, 2026. “—” means no dues figure is verified for that HOA in the database.
| HOA | City | Score | Dues / mo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coronado Shores | Coronado | 68 Elevated | $831–$1,640 |
| Seascape Sur | Solana Beach | 60 Elevated | $960–$1,076 |
| Pacific Gate | San Diego | 49 Moderate | $2,300 |
| Discovery at Cortez Hill | San Diego | 46 Moderate | $1,189–$1,274 |
| Smart Corner | San Diego | 44 Moderate | $952–$1,072 |
| Del Mar Woods | Del Mar | 36 Moderate | $884 |
| Marina Del Mar HOA | Oceanside | 36 Moderate | $757 |
| North Coast Village HOA | Oceanside | 36 Moderate | $1,000 |
| Capri By The Sea | San Diego | 36 Moderate | $1,156–$1,354 |
| Pacific Pines Racquet Club | Encinitas | 35 Moderate | $471 |
| Acqua Vista Homeowners Association | San Diego | 34 Moderate | $913–$970 |
| Clinton Manor | San Diego | 34 Moderate | $1,110 |
| Palazzo Bernardo HOA | San Diego | 34 Moderate | $788–$820 |
| Ambiance HOA | San Marcos | 34 Moderate | $479 |
| City Front Terrace HOA | San Diego | 33 Moderate | $1,172–$1,187 |
| Savina | San Diego | 33 Moderate | $1,300 |
| Marina Towers HOA | Oceanside | 32 Moderate | $920 |
| Alta Owners Association | San Diego | 32 Moderate | $853–$893 |
| Diamond Terrace HOA | San Diego | 32 Moderate | $939–$974 |
| Doma Homeowners Association | San Diego | 32 Moderate | $854 |
| Harbor Club | San Diego | 32 Moderate | $1,412–$3,811 |
| Horizons | San Diego | 32 Moderate | $1,350 |
| Meridian | San Diego | 32 Moderate | $1,950 |
| Park Place | San Diego | 32 Moderate | $1,250 |
| Parkloft | San Diego | 32 Moderate | $1,022 |
| The Grande | San Diego | 32 Moderate | $1,350 |
| The Pinnacle | San Diego | 32 Moderate | $1,600 |
| Sommerset by the Lake HOA | San Marcos | 32 Moderate | $563 |
| El Cortez Owners Association | San Diego | 31 Moderate | $1,046 |
| The Landing | Coronado | 30 Moderate | $1,400–$1,500 |
| La Jolla Terrace | San Diego | 30 Moderate | $432–$624 |
| Villa Portofino HOA | San Diego | 30 Moderate | $170–$190 |
| Monarch Villas | Carlsbad | 28 Moderate | $585 |
| El Camino | Coronado | 28 Moderate | $818–$1,196 |
| La Princesa | Coronado | 28 Moderate | $1,735 |
| Jamacha Greens | El Cajon | 28 Moderate | $550–$650 |
| Aegea HOA | Oceanside | 28 Moderate | $625 |
| Sandpiper Cove HOA | Oceanside | 28 Moderate | $700 |
| Bayside | San Diego | 28 Moderate | $1,100 |
| Electra | San Diego | 28 Moderate | $1,450 |
| Sapphire Tower | San Diego | 28 Moderate | $1,350 |
| Shore Tower Owners’ Association, Inc. | San Diego | 28 Moderate | $1,283 |
| The Legend | San Diego | 28 Moderate | $1,400 |
| The Mark | San Diego | 28 Moderate | $850 |
| Anchorage Lane Homeowners Association | San Diego | 28 Moderate | — |
| Shore House at the Del | Coronado | 26 Moderate | $1,794 |
| Millers Ranch | Lemon Grove | 26 Moderate | $12–$42 |
| Bernardo Village Green | San Diego | 26 Moderate | $540–$765 |
| Chateau Del Mar | Del Mar | 25 Moderate | $702 |
How this watchlist works, and what it is not
Scores are HOAGrades risk scores (0–100, higher = riskier; Legal 30, Financial 30, Physical 20, Governance 20). Bands: Low, Moderate, Elevated, High, Insufficient data.
Dues acceleration (CAGR) is computed only from genuine dues-history years (distinct years, at least a 3-year span), never from seeded current-dues rows.
County percentile is the HOA’s dues position among San Diego County HOAs with verified dues.
What this is not: a do-not-buy list, a prediction, or a substitute for the resale disclosure package, reserve study, budget, insurance, and litigation documents. Verify every figure against those documents before making a buying decision. HOAs not on this list are not “safe” — 385 HOAs in the database still have insufficient data to score at all.
Updates: this watchlist is dated October 22, 2026. It should be refreshed when the Health Report is refreshed, or when a watch-now item changes status (a case settles, an assessment is levied or paid off, or dues move materially).
Companion publication: publish alongside the San Diego HOA Health Report (October 2026), at hoagrades.com/hoa-health-report/, with cross-links in both directions.
Own an HOA home in San Diego?
Join San Diego HOA Owners & Buyers, a free Facebook group where local owners compare dues, assessments, and board stories, and get first look at new HOAGrades data.
Join the group